Justice Initiative Says Nominees for ICC Prosecutor Need Additional Vetting
Today, the Open Society Justice Initiative and Women’s Initiatives for Gender Justice submitted an open letter to the Bureau of the International Criminal Court (ICC) Assembly of States Parties, asking for additional, robust vetting of all candidates nominated for the ICC’s next prosecutor.
In July 2020, the Committee for the Election of the Prosecutor narrowed a longlist of 14 candidates to: Morris A. Anyah (Nigeria), Fergal Gaynor (Ireland), Susan Okalany (Uganda), and Richard Roy (Canada).
While the search committee conducted a background check and security clearance of the longlisted candidates earlier this year, today’s letter calls on the Bureau to authorize additional vetting measures for any candidates who might be considered for election, including:
- conducting reputational interviews, including collecting views from current and former colleagues, supervisors, subordinates, and others who have interacted with the candidates in different capacities;
- carrying out an independence check and a government exposure check;
- investigating any identifying “red flags,” including any allegations of workplace misconduct; and
- pursuing responses from all national criminal record offices and any other information available from international organizations.
Fair, transparent, and professionally handled vetting is a common practice among national and other government appointments, but not for top positions at the ICC.
In December 2020, the ICC’s 123 member states will vote on and elect the new prosecutor, who will be elected for a nine-year, non-renewable term.
Groups Urge State Parties to ICC to Follow Transparent Process for Electing New Prosecutor
In an open letter, the Justice Initiative joins nine organizations in urging state parties to the International Criminal Court to adhere to the existing process of electing its next prosecutor, including refraining from nominating candidates not included in the shortlist released on June 30, 2020.
ICC Announces Prosecutor Nomination Short List, Justice Initiative Calls for Additional Actions to Ensure Merit
Following the International Criminal Court's release of shortlisted candidates for the role of prosecutor , the Justice Initiative calls on member states to ensure that the candidates embody outstanding professional merit and “high moral character,” a key requirement for the position.
Excellence, not Politics, should Choose the Judges at the ICC
Nominations and elections of judicial candidates at the International Criminal Court often overlook merit-based considerations in favor of political interests. It's time for reform.